"The Mariners 20" voting

[pjennings]

Monty and Serge to run the Academy so we still have Serges network. Jacko for the first team.

 

[Josho Howe]

Obvious pickings

 

[Josho Howe]

In all seriousness though............that was tough to narrow down.



Honourable mentions: Mile, Monty, Patty Z, Tommy H, Tommy Rogic

 

[Nik Mrdjas Disco Bikkie]

you both forgot hutch

Great club man, not the best player though

 

[booney]

1.Ryan
2.Rogic
3.McBreen
4.Zwaanswijk
5.Jedinak
6.Cummings
7.Pain
8.Montgomery
9.Nisbet
10.Tulio

 

[priorpeter]

Who would be your manager? McKinna, Arnold, Montgomery, Jackson?

Cheers Mulvey’s crying

 

[booney]

11.Vukovic
12.Pondeljak
13.Rose(J)
14.Sainsbury
15.Wilkinson
16.Hutchison
17.Doka
18.Roux
19.Farrell
20.Silvera
Difficult to leave out-Simon,Gumprecht,Nkololo,Perez,Balard,Triantis and McGlinchey.

 

[booney]

Shit list
1.Hoole
2.Bosnar
3.Melling
4.Kennedy
5.Graham
6.Oar
7.Mane
8.Asdrubal
9.Murray
10.Mcallister

 

[Lunchbox Legend]

 

[booney]

I forgot Mitch Austin for the shit list.

 

[sydmariner]

View attachment 3691

Obvious pickings

You forgot disco,Matt millar & snake.

 

[sydmariner]

11.Vukovic
12.Pondeljak
13.Rose(J)
14.Sainsbury
15.Wilkinson
16.Hutchison
17.Doka
18.Roux
19.Farrell
20.Silvera
Difficult to leave out-Simon,Gumprecht,Nkololo,Perez,Balard,Triantis and McGlinchey.

Mcglinchey tried to sue the club.

 

[sydmariner]

Shit list
1.Hoole
2.Bosnar
3.Melling
4.Kennedy
5.Graham
6.Oar
7.Mane
8.Asdrubal
9.Murray
10.Mcallister

McAllister was a club legend imo.

 

[Josho Howe]

You forgot disco,Matt millar & snake.

Come on mate, it's pretty easy to run out of room on the shit list

 

[bikinigirl]

. i don't like to play favourites, so from my perspective this can't be done ... happy for other people to have a crack though

. but i am intrigued - which criteria are people making their 'best' judgement on?

. obviously it is a combination of things, but it is the little things that must sway personal opinion one way of another. the fact that it is not a 'best 11' adds a certain amount of freedom - but that leads to more choices. i'm probably more interested in people's criteria than their actual choice

. whadyareckon?

 

[pjennings]

Winning 🏆definitely helps.But Matty never won anything here. I'm going to find it hard to leave him out. Coastie, all time leading goal scorer, we didn't won't him when he went to Sydney but he still bleeds yellow and navy.

 

[BaysideMariner]

. i don't like to play favourites, so from my perspective this can't be done ... happy for other people to have a crack though

. but i am intrigued - which criteria are people making their 'best' judgement on?

. obviously it is a combination of things, but it is the little things that must sway personal opinion one way of another. the fact that it is not a 'best 11' adds a certain amount of freedom - but that leads to more choices. i'm probably more interested in people's criteria than their actual choice

. whadyareckon?

My criteria was who did I admire for their skills, passion for the club, whether I could handle seeing them in oppositions jerseys(Matt Simon) etc... It was tough. Generally how they made me feel when they played for us.....

 

[booney]

Mcglinchey tried to sue the club.

I am judging him on his playing ability-certainly his first stint.McAllister's first game for us was a cracker but after that he was a disappointment to me at least

 

[booney]

You forgot disco,Matt millar & snake.

Yep and I also forgot Ross McCormack

 

[Ironbark]

At this rate Nizzy seems a dead cert to make this all time list