Round One Local Thread

[northernspirit]

yeah he was on a power trip big time, wanted to stamp his authority on the game and in doing so was WAY too heavy handed... in saying that we need to shut up and accept the decision, doesnt matter what we say it isnt going to change, we cant afford players being carded

 

[dibo]

Even though the Captain is meant to converse with the ref, reaching for your cards when asked a question is lame IMO.

Bit harsh if that is how it is.

the captain has no special right to speak to the referee. the referee's decision is final and any dissent by word or action can be punished.

not saying dissent is never 'unjustified' in the real world, just that they're the laws of the game.

 

[Ted]

Even though the Captain is meant to converse with the ref, reaching for your cards when asked a question is lame IMO.

Bit harsh if that is how it is.

the captain has no special right to speak to the referee. the referee's decision is final and any dissent by word or action can be punished.

not saying dissent is never 'unjustified' in the real world, just that they're the laws of the game.

I agree mate, but a ref should 'know the rules' and the be able to tell difference between awarding a indirect or a direct free kick and when and why each should be given. Giving yellow cards to players questioning him about his decision when he has has no clue and being paid for it is simply wrong.

So this means a ref can show a card when ever he pleases without any reason and no one can question why?

By all accounts a player got a yellow for dissent, then he made a challenge the ref deemed as studs up even thoguh the other team denied it as being dangerous or studs up and sent him off with a 2nd yellow in as many minutes?

 

[hilly1981]

Hilly
Ourimbah AA9's were never told that that game was moved to EGO they were told it was cancelled!!! Ourimbah AA9 is my husbands team and he is very pissed off because they all wanted to play!

That really sucks. If I were in your husbands shoes I would be pretty damn pissed as well.

I had a feeling there may have been a miscommunication or something, since not 1 player from Ourimbah showed up. Any ideas who advised that the game was canned and not moved? We were advised early saturday afternoon that the game was shifted to EGO for a 9am kickoff.

 

[mariners4ever]

Hilly
Ourimbah AA9's were never told that that game was moved to EGO they were told it was cancelled!!! Ourimbah AA9 is my husbands team and he is very pissed off because they all wanted to play!

We were advised early saturday afternoon that the game was shifted to EGO for a 9am kickoff.

you were probably advised earlier then anyone else because they had to inform all doyalson teams that were meant to be playing at home

 

[northernspirit]

Even though the Captain is meant to converse with the ref, reaching for your cards when asked a question is lame IMO.

Bit harsh if that is how it is.

the captain has no special right to speak to the referee. the referee's decision is final and any dissent by word or action can be punished.

not saying dissent is never 'unjustified' in the real world, just that they're the laws of the game.

I agree mate, but a ref should 'know the rules' and the be able to tell difference between awarding a indirect or a direct free kick and when and why each should be given. Giving yellow cards to players questioning him about his decision when he has has no clue and being paid for it is simply wrong.

So this means a ref can show a card when ever he pleases without any reason and no one can question why?

By all accounts a player got a yellow for dissent, then he made a challenge the ref deemed as studs up even thoguh the other team denied it as being dangerous or studs up and sent him off with a 2nd yellow in as many minutes?

can there be grounds to appeal what happened?

 

[marinermick]

It may also be the manner you guys speak to the referee and could even be a cultural difference for some of the players in both the language and how the game is being refereed.

I know the week before when we played you there were some players qucik to temper even though the game and tackles were benign. Some much so that we were actually called names after some strong but not necessarily malicious tackles.

 

[Paolo]

We got Gosford we will pump them they are HOPELESS...Route one football is from the dark ages and fitzy loves that crap. Another easy Grand Final win coming our way..

Rofl at you publically slating them and then conceding 4 goalsand only drawing 4-4 against 10 men...bl

 

[Omni]

Absolutely agree with Mick, the way things are said is very importat, if you're angry and yelling you'll think you're saying "excuse me sir, I respectfully disagree" but the ref will hear 'WHAT THE F... YOU F... JOKE!" Where as the actual words are somewhere in the middle. I always tell players I'm not going to take any crap and if they ask 'can I talk' I'll explain if it's polite, but remember I won't change my mind.

Captains have no special right as far as I'm concerned (and given most captains don't wear armbands I'm not going to know who it was an hour down the track).

 

[marinermick]

(and given most captains don't wear armbands I'm not going to know who it was an hour down the track).

wild stab in the dark here Chris but wouldn't the captains be the guys that you do the toss with at the start and don't you write their numbers in your little book?

 

[Ted]

Even though the Captain is meant to converse with the ref, reaching for your cards when asked a question is lame IMO.

Bit harsh if that is how it is.

the captain has no special right to speak to the referee. the referee's decision is final and any dissent by word or action can be punished.

not saying dissent is never 'unjustified' in the real world, just that they're the laws of the game.

I agree mate, but a ref should 'know the rules' and the be able to tell difference between awarding a indirect or a direct free kick and when and why each should be given. Giving yellow cards to players questioning him about his decision when he has has no clue and being paid for it is simply wrong.

So this means a ref can show a card when ever he pleases without any reason and no one can question why?

By all accounts a player got a yellow for dissent, then he made a challenge the ref deemed as studs up even thoguh the other team denied it as being dangerous or studs up and sent him off with a 2nd yellow in as many minutes?

can there be grounds to appeal what happened?

No mate,  I have it on good authority that the player in question will likely be sidelined for a month or more. It was how he carried on after the game was over and what he said that is the problem not what he did or said on the pitch. everything has all been reported. I have spoke to a club official who witnessed the incident. There is no way out of this, when dealing with a ref, its better to shut up and play the game and not stew on calls you deem unjsut or incorrect.

Sometimes you play 11 and have a ref. Sometimes you play 11 and a ref. Either way, just shut up and play football and hopefully make the final score in your favour...

 

[BrisRecky]

well just went to watch Wyoming vs SEU- u21s
thats Herbs team...
i predicted a win- but not like this
lost count after 7-0 halftime
I think end score was 15-18...nil!
given that a red card was recieved 3 mins into 2nd half (SEU player took down WMG attacker last man)
and 3-4 goals offside in 2nd half
still major mismatch in which Wyoming were in cruise control
1st half was just crazy!

GO THE TIGE'S....( the keepers not a bad bloke either)..17-blot....nice little padding for the G.D for the year

 

[Wilson]

We got Gosford we will pump them they are HOPELESS...Route one football is from the dark ages and fitzy loves that crap. Another easy Grand Final win coming our way..

Rofl at you publically slating them and then conceding 4 goalsand only drawing 4-4 against 10 men...bl

Ha at you thinking I actually play for Umina. Fitzy and I go way back just taking the piss

 

[Paolo]

We got Gosford we will pump them they are HOPELESS...Route one football is from the dark ages and fitzy loves that crap. Another easy Grand Final win coming our way..

Rofl at you publically slating them and then conceding 4 goalsand only drawing 4-4 against 10 men...bl

Ha at you thinking I actually play for Umina. Fitzy and I go way back just taking the piss

Bl me and my trusting nature

 

[Ziggy]

Hilly
Ourimbah AA9's were never told that that game was moved to EGO they were told it was cancelled!!! Ourimbah AA9 is my husbands team and he is very pissed off because they all wanted to play!

That really sucks. If I were in your husbands shoes I would be pretty damn pissed as well.

I had a feeling there may have been a miscommunication or something, since not 1 player from Ourimbah showed up. Any ideas who advised that the game was canned and not moved? We were advised early saturday afternoon that the game was shifted to EGO for a 9am kickoff.

Apparently CCF sent a email though to Ourimbah late Saturday but no one checked the email - same thing happened to Ourimbah AA6's - pretty piss poor excuse. I don't think Ourimbah has a permanent fixtures officer they sure need one. We had a great one up until last year but she resigned.

 

[Gibbsy]

We got Gosford we will pump them they are HOPELESS...Route one football is from the dark ages and fitzy loves that crap. Another easy Grand Final win coming our way..

Rofl at you publically slating them and then conceding 4 goalsand only drawing 4-4 against 10 men...bl

Ha at you thinking I actually play for Umina. Fitzy and I go way back just taking the piss

Haha funny.
good to see you dont play for those Umina filth, but in all honesty Gosford were for large parts the better side on Sunday. Using width, good passing game and a only a few long balls. alot has changed i would say.

 

[Wilson]

We got Gosford we will pump them they are HOPELESS...Route one football is from the dark ages and fitzy loves that crap. Another easy Grand Final win coming our way..

Rofl at you publically slating them and then conceding 4 goalsand only drawing 4-4 against 10 men...bl

Ha at you thinking I actually play for Umina. Fitzy and I go way back just taking the piss

Haha funny.
good to see you dont play for those Umina filth, but in all honesty Gosford were for large parts the better side on Sunday. Using width, good passing game and a only a few long balls. alot has changed i would say.

Their "A" game will be required for round 2!!

 

[tugga]

I play AA9's for Ourimbah and that was f**king bullshit that they f**ked up. We should get to replay that game.

 

[Ted]

Even though the Captain is meant to converse with the ref, reaching for your cards when asked a question is lame IMO.

Bit harsh if that is how it is.

the captain has no special right to speak to the referee. the referee's decision is final and any dissent by word or action can be punished.

not saying dissent is never 'unjustified' in the real world, just that they're the laws of the game.

I agree mate, but a ref should 'know the rules' and the be able to tell difference between awarding a indirect or a direct free kick and when and why each should be given. Giving yellow cards to players questioning him about his decision when he has has no clue and being paid for it is simply wrong.

So this means a ref can show a card when ever he pleases without any reason and no one can question why?

By all accounts a player got a yellow for dissent, then he made a challenge the ref deemed as studs up even thoguh the other team denied it as being dangerous or studs up and sent him off with a 2nd yellow in as many minutes?

can there be grounds to appeal what happened?

No mate,  I have it on good authority that the player in question will likely be sidelined for a month or more. It was how he carried on after the game was over and what he said that is the problem not what he did or said on the pitch. everything has all been reported. I have spoke to a club official who witnessed the incident. There is no way out of this, when dealing with a ref, its better to shut up and play the game and not stew on calls you deem unjsut or incorrect.

Sometimes you play 11 and have a ref. Sometimes you play 11 and a ref. Either way, just shut up and play football and hopefully make the final score in your favour...

Well he only copped a 1 game suspension thankfully

 

[hilly1981]

I play AA9's for Ourimbah and that was f**king bullshit that they f**ked up. We should get to replay that game.

Yeah it was a stuff up and a half wasnt it. Must be really frustrating for you and your team. I would be blowing up as well thats for sure.