Who would you rather have at the club next year?

[Wombat]

Mulvey, while proving to be a piss poor coach thus far has decided he has a hate for our best player Tommy H. My question is.............who would you rather be here next season?
Mr 5% win ratio or a quality Footballer?
Is Mulvey right and running around hacking people and passing to invisible teammates the go or should we be building our team around a quality Footballer. Should fat arsed Scummers be allowed to dawdle around the pitch, contributing next to nothing or should a artisan be paired with a worker in midfield to deliver a powerful combo?

 

[greenlig]

Mate you are looking for easy points here! If only the club knew what the fans were thinking

 

[greenlig]

Should fat arsed Scummers be allowed to dawdle around the pitch, contributing next to nothing or should a artisan be paired with a worker in midfield to deliver a powerful combo?

Sounds like the start of a manifesto...

 

[turbo]

Thought this was going to be a discussion of available coaches and was quite interested to see what names were thrown around.

As for the question above I don't think a MM v Tom H narrative really helps anyone, I want MM gone but its performance based rather than worrying about a feud we have little inside info on. If leaving is framed around Tom H it takes legitimacy from the performance reasoning.

 

[Forum Phoenix]

Marvin. Oh alright... and Tom.

 

[Big Al]

Love the what’s not to like on the Mulvey option. Absolute gold

 

[Big Al]

millar and his mum voted for millar in the last poll. Will Mulvey and his mum give him a vote. No one else surely thinks he knows what he is doing

 

[Fadetoblack944]

Must say I'm really looking forward to seeing Tom H spank us at another club next year as a big F U to mulvey/Montgomery

 

[marinermick]

No A-League club will pick up Hiariej as a precious visa spot given his injury track record.

 

[Fadetoblack944]

No A-League club will pick up Hiariej as a precious visa spot given his injury track record.

I thought Brisbane where interested earlier on in the year?

 

[BrisRecky]

Hell, the Dutchman by a rural kilometer and I’m not even being racially byast
I must say , I was keen when Mulvey was announced...that, like many others happiness, evaporated REAL QUICK
So, yeah.....
#HupTommyHup #HiariejKrishna #AllHailHiareijism #f**kOffMulvey

 

[Coastalraider]

No A-League club will pick up Hiariej as a precious visa spot given his injury track record.

That is the elephant in the room right now, it’s turned into a Mulvey vs Our Saviour cknverstation, But our saviour has spent more time on the sideline than we would want for a marquee player.

For one reason or another he had only player 66% of matches since his arrival, that’s a low return for a marquee.

While he is arguable the most talented player in our squad, there have been legitimate games when he has failed to assert himself on the midfield. There have been more when he has shown his absolute class though.

I think a lot of the love for him is that he actually wants to play for us, he has skill, and he has been Portia’s as the face of the ‘fans vs Mulvey’ campaign.

We should sign him, because it’s very unlikely we could replace him, but let’s nit pretend he doesn’t have his faults.

 

[NoDiggity]

No A-League club will pick up Hiariej as a precious visa spot given his injury track record.

Brisbane, one melb club (not sure which) and one other club all contacted Toms agent prior to the January window.

 

[turbo]

While he is arguable the most talented player in our squad, there have been legitimate games when he has failed to assert himself on the midfield. There have been more when he has shown his absolute class though.

This. If we got Tom at his best and fully fit for a season we’d have sold him off already and made a nice sum from it. He’s had his share of injuries and whatever went on with MM but it doesn’t seem like the club has given any of the players the chance to be their best with the strength and conditioning staffing issues.

 

[pjennings]

This. If we got Tom at his best and fully fit for a season we’d have sold him off already and made a nice sum from it. He’s had his share of injuries and whatever went on with MM but it doesn’t seem like the club has given any of the players the chance to be their best with the strength and conditioning staffing issues.

So bring back Andrew Clark. While you are at it Creepy can take back over from Nash.

 

[soccer mad]

Some filthy rich Arab who's looking for a new hobby to splash his cash some Soudi trying to gain global credibility.

 

[true believer]

better still who was the better owner clive palmer or the pikey ?

 

[turbo]

better still who was the better owner clive palmer or the pikey ?

I'm not sure clive palmer was the better owner of anything..

 

[soccer mad]

We have the correct colour scheme for the Palmer United party and a new logo PU

 

[MagpieMariner]

Some filthy rich Arab who's looking for a new hobby to splash his cash some Soudi trying to gain global credibility.

If a Saudi buys us, I will definitely be out of here.