Matty Simon V Josh Kennedy

[Forum Phoenix]

 

[Arabmariner]

Tbh I don't think any of our strikers, and it would be the same with Matty, are helped by PV's 'system'.

The way we play atm..... y'know like the away team even at home leaves our strikers hung out to dry imo.

 

[Dr Nick]

yep. im over verbeek tbh

 

[Blackadder]

Until PV fails to qualify for a WC he will be safe.
As for the question, give it about 3 years and undoubtably Matt Simon will be ahead of Jesus.

 

[Kareem]

Until PV fails to qualify for a WC he will be safe.
As for the question, give it about 3 years and undoubtably Matt Simon will be ahead of Jesus.

i chose No
if there was a 3 year option...maybe. Especially at the developmental rate he is at.
Kennedy is in his prime...Simon has a long way to go yet.

 

[Wombat]

Kennedy is pretty toothless at international level but would be a revelation in HAL.

Simon will be better in a couple of years due to his tenacity and fitness.

 

[Jesus]

Until PV fails to qualify for a WC he will be safe.
As for the question, give it about 3 years and undoubtably Matt Simon will be ahead of Jesus.

Pim will leave post world cup

 

[hasbeen]

"Could Matty Simon offer more to the National Team than Josh kennedy? "

Our cat could.

 

[centre mid]

maybe off the bench....but no atm....matty hasnt scored enough goals this season compared to jesus with his Japanese team....

 

[Forum Phoenix]

"Could Matty Simon offer more to the National Team than Josh kennedy? "

Our cat could.

Well I'll give you it would undoubtedly be faster and more agile... but it's a cat...
There's no way it should get a start over my dog!

 

[Not Aloi$i FC]

Kennedy is much, much better in the air and technically is much, much better as well. Simon is a little better in picking up scraps than Kennedy is, he's scored quite a few goals from big defensive mistakes but it comes back to the old argument of "he wouldn't score if he wasn't in that position", so he gets points for that at least.

If you put them in the same attack, Kennedy would score a lot more goals than Simon. I can't help but feel he would be perfect for you guys.

 

[Forum Phoenix]

If you put them in the same attack, Kennedy would score a lot more goals than Simon. I can't help but feel he would be perfect for you guys.

No he wouldn't fit into our style of play, didn't you know that we like to play a short passing game now?

TBF, anyone who could score more than once would be a welcome addition to our strike force.

 

[Not Aloi$i FC]

I'll give you guys credit. With your defensive record until recently, one goal is all you needed in most games.

 

[Forum Phoenix]

"I'll give you guys credit..."



Are you suuuureeee your a Sydney fan?

:-*

 

[elevated position]

Josh will be looking for aclub in four weeks

 

[Forum Phoenix]

Empty the bank Lyall.

Then we could really tell how good he is! ;D

 

[coast]

i wouldn't be surprised if he got an extension or was picked up by another j league club.

 

[Forum Phoenix]

Think nagoya would be pretty happy with him.
Just whether we can get him on loan?

 

[mariners4ever]

prove me wrong but wouldnt it be because they season is almost over and he'll want to keep fit ahead of the world cup ???

 

[Forum Phoenix]

Yeah thats what I'm thinking. But not sure on his contract so thinking a loan if anything.

But he will try OS first I would think.